Mary Morstan, a significant character in Arthur Conan Doyle’s Sherlock Holmes series, particularly in “The Sign of Four,” has sparked mixed reactions among readers and viewers. Her portrayal in the BBC Sherlock adaptation has only added to the debate.
This article delves into why people harbor negative feelings towards Mary Morstan, exploring her character, actions, and impact on the storyline. Additionally, we’ll answer frequently asked questions related to her character and provide a comprehensive understanding of her role in the Sherlock Holmes universe.
Who is Mary Morstan?
Mary Morstan is introduced in Arthur Conan Doyle’s novel “The Sign of Four.” She is a client of Sherlock Holmes and later becomes Dr. John Watson’s wife. Her character is depicted as a strong, intelligent, and caring woman who plays a crucial role in the story’s development. Despite these qualities, Mary Morstan’s character has been a subject of controversy and debate among fans of Sherlock Holmes.
Why Do People Hate Mary Morstan?
The animosity towards Mary Morstan stems from several factors, including her actions, the way she is portrayed in different adaptations, and her impact on the dynamic between Sherlock Holmes and Dr. John Watson. Here are some reasons why people might dislike her character:
Interruption of the Holmes-Watson Dynamic
One of the primary reasons for the dislike is that Mary Morstan’s presence disrupts the iconic partnership between Sherlock Holmes and Dr. John Watson. Fans of the original duo often feel that her introduction alters the chemistry and focus of the stories.
Portrayal in the BBC Series
In the BBC adaptation “Sherlock,” Mary Morstan, played by Amanda Abbington, is given a more complex and darker backstory. This portrayal includes her being a former assassin, which deviates significantly from the original character in the books. Some fans dislike this reinterpretation, feeling it strays too far from Doyle’s creation.
Controversial Actions
Mary’s actions, particularly in the BBC series, contribute to her unpopularity. Her involvement in various deceptions and the shooting of Sherlock Holmes, albeit under complex circumstances, left many viewers conflicted about her character.
Lack of Depth in the Original Text
In Doyle’s original stories, some readers find Mary Morstan to be underdeveloped compared to other characters. This perceived lack of depth might contribute to a lack of attachment or interest, leading to indifference or dislike.
Does Mary Morstan Die in Sherlock?
How Did Mary Morstan Die?
In the BBC series “Sherlock,” Mary Morstan dies in the episode “The Six Thatchers.” She sacrifices herself to save Sherlock Holmes by jumping in front of a bullet meant for him. This act of selflessness is both a redemption for her past actions and a tragic end to her character.
How Does Mary Morstan Die in Sherlock Holmes?
In the original Arthur Conan Doyle stories, Mary Morstan’s death is mentioned but not elaborated upon. She is said to have died before the events of “The Adventure of the Norwood Builder,” where Dr. Watson refers to his wife as having passed away. The cause of her death is not specified.
How Does Conan Doyle Present Mary Morstan in Chapter 2?
In Chapter 2 of “The Sign of Four,” Mary Morstan is introduced as a young woman in distress. She approaches Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson for help in solving the mystery of her missing father and the pearls she has been receiving annually.
Description and Personality
Conan Doyle presents Mary Morstan as a gentle and composed woman. She is described as attractive but not overly striking, with an air of quiet strength and dignity. Her calm demeanor and clear, concise narration of her troubles impress both Holmes and Watson.
How Does Mary Morstan Help Sherlock?
Mary Morstan plays a crucial role in the plot of “The Sign of Four.” Her initial approach to Holmes sets the entire story in motion. Her bravery and determination are evident as she faces dangerous situations alongside Holmes and Watson. In the BBC adaptation, her skills and intelligence are further highlighted, making her a valuable ally to Sherlock in solving cases.
How is Mary Morstan Presented in Chapter 2?
Initial Meeting
Mary Morstan is presented as a woman in need of assistance, setting the stage for the adventure that follows. Her introduction is significant as it establishes her as a central character in the unfolding mystery.
Interaction with Holmes and Watson
Her interaction with Holmes and Watson in Chapter 2 shows her to be articulate, composed, and honest. She gains the trust of both men, which is crucial for the development of the story.
Is Mary Morstan Dead?
In the Original Stories
Yes, Mary Morstan is dead by the time “The Adventure of the Norwood Builder” takes place. Her death is mentioned in passing by Dr. Watson but is not a focal point of the story.
In the BBC Series
Mary Morstan dies in “The Six Thatchers” episode, sacrificing herself to save Sherlock Holmes.
Is Mary Morstan Right or Left Handed?
The original stories and adaptations do not explicitly state whether Mary Morstan is right or left-handed. This detail is not considered significant in her character development or the plot.
What is the Name of Mary Morstan’s Employer?
In “The Sign of Four,” Mary Morstan does not have a specific employer mentioned. Her role in the story revolves around her personal quest to solve the mystery of her father’s disappearance and the pearls she has been receiving.
What Was Mary Morstan’s Father’s Name in The Sign of Four?
Mary Morstan’s father is Captain Arthur Morstan. He was an officer in the British army who disappeared under mysterious circumstances, leading to the events of “The Sign of Four.”
Who Plays Mary Morstan in BBC Sherlock?
In the BBC series “Sherlock,” Mary Morstan is portrayed by actress Amanda Abbington. Her portrayal adds depth and complexity to the character, including a dark and intriguing backstory as a former assassin.
Who Sent Mary Morstan the Pearls?
In “The Sign of Four,” the pearls are sent to Mary Morstan by Thaddeus Sholto. He sends them as a gesture of goodwill and to assuage his guilt over his father’s involvement in the events leading to Captain Morstan’s disappearance and death.
Why Does Mary Morstan Come to See Sherlock Holmes?
Mary Morstan seeks Sherlock Holmes’ help to solve the mystery of her missing father and the pearls she has been receiving annually. Her visit to Holmes sets off the chain of events that unfold in “The Sign of Four.”
Will Mary Morstan Die in Sherlock?
In the BBC series, Mary Morstan’s death occurs in “The Six Thatchers” episode. Since the series has concluded, there will be no further exploration of her character beyond her death in this episode.
Events in Mary Morstan’s Life
| Event | Description |
|---|---|
| Introduction in “The Sign of Four” | Approaches Holmes and Watson for help with her father’s disappearance |
| Relationship with Watson | Marries Dr. John Watson |
| Role in BBC Series | Portrayed as a former assassin with a complex backstory |
| Death in BBC Series | Sacrifices herself to save Sherlock Holmes in “The Six Thatchers” episode |
| Death in Original Stories | Mentioned as having died before “The Adventure of the Norwood Builder” |
Conclusion
Mary Morstan is a character that evokes mixed reactions among fans of Sherlock Holmes. Whether it is her role in disrupting the Holmes-Watson dynamic, her controversial portrayal in the BBC series, or her actions and development in the original stories, she remains a figure of significant debate. Despite the varying opinions, her character adds depth and complexity to the Sherlock Holmes universe, making her an essential part of the story’s fabric.
By exploring the different facets of Mary Morstan’s character, from her introduction in “The Sign of Four” to her portrayal in modern adaptations, we gain a comprehensive understanding of why she is a polarizing figure. Her bravery, intelligence, and the mysteries surrounding her life and death continue to captivate audiences, ensuring that Mary Morstan remains a topic of discussion among Sherlock Holmes enthusiasts for years to come.
FAQs
Why Do People Hate Mary Morstan?
Mary Morstan is disliked by some fans due to her disruption of the Holmes-Watson dynamic, her controversial actions in the BBC series, and her perceived lack of depth in the original stories.
Does Mary Morstan Die in Sherlock?
Yes, Mary Morstan dies in the BBC series “Sherlock,” sacrificing herself to save Sherlock Holmes.
How Did Mary Morstan Die?
In the BBC series, she dies by jumping in front of a bullet meant for Sherlock Holmes. In the original stories, her death is mentioned but not elaborated upon.
How Does Mary Morstan Help Sherlock?
Mary Morstan helps Sherlock Holmes by bringing him the mystery of her father’s disappearance and the pearls. In the BBC series, her skills and intelligence make her a valuable ally in solving cases.
Who Plays Mary Morstan in BBC Sherlock?
Mary Morstan is portrayed by Amanda Abbington in the BBC series “Sherlock.”